Questions
Can I Bill Clients for AI? Time, Subscriptions and Value Fees
You can bill actual time spent using AI, not time it saved; subscriptions are overhead; value fees stay lawful. What ABA 512, Texas 705, Virginia 1901 and California say.
On this page
Yes, with limits. You can bill the actual time you spend prompting, reviewing and correcting AI output at your normal rate. You cannot bill the hours the tool saved. General AI subscriptions are overhead and cannot be passed through; a matter-specific AI charge needs disclosure and consent. Fixed and value fees remain lawful even when AI made the work fast.
The short answer by category
| What you want to charge | Allowed? | Authority (as of September 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Minutes actually spent prompting, reading, verifying, correcting | Yes, at your usual hourly rate | ABA Formal Opinion 512 (Jul 2024); Texas Opinion 705 (Feb 2025) |
| The hours the task "would have taken" without AI | No | Texas 705; Florida 24-1 (Jan 2024); ABA 512 |
| A general AI subscription (Claude Team, ChatGPT Business, a Harvey or Legora seat) | No; overhead, like Westlaw or Word | ABA 512; California Practical Guidance (14 May 2026) |
| A matter-specific AI cost (usage-based processing of one client's documents) | Yes, at cost, if agreed in advance | ABA 512; California (May 2026) |
| A mark-up on that matter-specific cost | Only with informed written consent | California (May 2026) |
| A fixed or value-based fee for work AI made faster | Yes, if the fee is reasonable | Virginia LEO 1901 (approved 24 Nov 2025) |
The regulation-section page on billing walks through each opinion in detail; this page gives you the rules and the wording to apply tomorrow.
Actual time, yes; saved time, no
The day OpenAI announced Astra for Law, a Hacker News thread with 655 comments produced the line every client is now thinking: "Cool, now you can pay an attorney $500/hr for them to prompt Astra for 30 minutes, and bill you like they spent the normal 8 hours" (Hacker News, 17 Sep 2026). The ethics opinions close exactly that door.
ABA Formal Opinion 512 (29 July 2024) says an hourly lawyer may bill the time actually spent on a matter, including time spent prompting and reviewing AI output, and not the time the tool saved. Texas Opinion 705 (February 2025) puts it bluntly: a lawyer "cannot charge for time 'saved' by AI". Florida's Opinion 24-1 reached the same result a year earlier. Under an hourly retainer the promise is hours, and an hour is an hour.
The scale of the gap is why regulators care. Modern Counsel put the average Big Law associate rate at $798 an hour on 3 September 2026, up 33% since 2023. Thirty minutes of prompting at that rate is $399; the eight hours it replaced would have been $6,384. Verification time, by contrast, is real work: opening every citation, reading the passage relied on and running a citator check is billable, and the citation-checking protocol shows how long it honestly takes. Time spent rescuing a hopeless first draft is a harder sell; Rule 1.5 reasonableness still applies, and a client will not pay twice for one memo.
Subscriptions are overhead; disbursements need consent
Every current opinion treats a general AI licence the way it treats a research database. ABA 512 calls subscriptions overhead. California's Board of Trustees approved updated Practical Guidance on 14 May 2026 that says general AI subscriptions are overhead and that AI costs cannot be marked up without informed written consent (Wilson Elser summary).
What that covers, at September 2026 prices: Claude Team at $25 per seat, ChatGPT Business at $25 per seat monthly, CoCounsel Legal's published range of $104 to $639 per user per month, Harvey at an estimated $1,000 to $1,200 per seat per month with a 20-seat minimum, and Legora from about $3,000 per user per year (the last two are secondary-source estimates; see the pricing guide). None of these is a disbursement. Build them into your rates the way you built in Westlaw.
The exception is a cost that attaches to one client's matter: a usage-based charge for processing that client's data room, or an agent run billed per session-hour and per token. That can be recovered at cost, provided the engagement letter says so before the spend. Keep the vendor invoice; a client who asks for it is entitled to see it.
Value fees are the way out
Virginia LEO 1901, approved by the Supreme Court of Virginia on 24 November 2025, is the opinion most partners have not read and should: a reasonable value-based fee need not be reduced because AI saved time. The client buys the answer, not the clock.
The economics already point that way. Clio's 2025 Legal Trends Report found 74% of hourly billable tasks have automation potential and that lawyers bill 2.9 of every 8 hours worked. Katy Young of Ad Astra Law Group, a six-lawyer San Francisco firm, told Above the Law in February 2026: "It used to take two days to draft a complaint, now it takes me two and a half hours" (Above the Law). The firm did not replace a departing eighth-year; staffing costs fell 27% and profits rose. Crosby, the "AI-native" firm that raised $60m in March 2026, bills $250 to $1,000 per contract and never by the hour. Jordan Furlong's summary is the one to remember: "Billing by the hour is like billing by the kilometre" (Furlong, 25 Aug 2026). The billable-hour guide covers who keeps the AI dividend under each model.
What clients are doing about it
Clients are not waiting for the bar. Meta's outside-counsel guidelines, reported in March 2026, refuse payment for tasks AI could have done (Josef Legal); Morgan Stanley and Citigroup are pushing firms to pass on savings (Sherwood, 2 Sep 2026), and Citi asks firms to document them. Axiom's July 2026 survey of 528 in-house leaders found 92% expect or negotiate AI-related rate cuts, though few get them. Peter Winders of Carlton Fields wrote in March 2026 that most client guidelines he sees now require naming the tool, written permission and cost-saving estimates (Carlton Fields).
Then there is the client with a chatbot. A Lawyertalk thread with 492 upvotes in July 2026 described the new bill dispute: "Clients don't like their bill? Run it through ChatGPT and send its response to me asking me to defend XYZ." Clio's numbers explain the mood: 78% of clients want AI disclosure and 35% of lawyers rarely give it. The disclosure rules vary by jurisdiction; the invoice is where clients find out anyway.
Engagement-letter language that works
Adapt these to your bar's rules and your fee model. They are drafting starting points, not a substitute for your own regulator's opinion.
1. Use of AI tools (all matters)
We use artificial-intelligence tools, including [Claude / Microsoft 365 Copilot /
Harvey], to assist with research, document review and drafting. A lawyer reviews
and remains responsible for all work product. We do not enter your confidential
information into tools that use it for model training. You may ask us not to use
AI tools on your matter, and we will discuss any effect on cost and timing.
2. Charges (hourly matters)
Our hourly charges reflect time actually spent, including time spent instructing,
reviewing and verifying the output of AI tools. We do not charge for time that
those tools save. The cost of our general AI subscriptions is included in our
rates and is not charged separately.
3. Matter-specific AI costs
Where a matter requires usage-based AI processing (for example, automated review
of a data room billed to us per document or per run), we will tell you the
estimated cost in advance, charge it at cost without mark-up, and provide the
vendor invoice on request.
4. Fixed fee (where used)
The fee for [scope] is EUR/USD [amount], payable [terms]. The fee reflects the
value and complexity of the work and the responsibility we assume; it does not
vary with the time we spend or the tools we use to complete it.
What to do this week
- Read your own jurisdiction's opinion. The state-by-state guide lists all 17 US jurisdictions with formal AI opinions as of June 2026; European lawyers should read the CCBE guide of 2 October 2025 and their bar's rules.
- Audit last month's narratives for phrases such as "drafted memorandum" that recorded pre-AI hours. Bill the minutes; if the minutes look thin, the fee model is the problem, not the timesheet.
- Move the subscription line out of any disbursement schedule and into overhead.
- Pick one recurring product, such as an NDA review or a standard lease, and price it as a fixed fee this quarter, with the value fee clause above.
- Write the AI paragraph into the engagement letter template before the next client asks. Your firm AI policy should say the same thing internally.
The final module of the AI Lab for Lawyers course covers what AI does to the economics of legal work, including fee models and disclosure, alongside the regulatory rules. Small firms that want the value-fee model without enterprise pricing will find the small-firm guide a practical next read.
Frequently asked questions
Can a lawyer charge for time saved by using AI?
No, not under an hourly arrangement. Texas Opinion 705 (February 2025) and ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 2024) both say an hourly fee covers time actually spent, so a task that took thirty minutes with AI is billed as thirty minutes. If you want to be paid for the result rather than the clock, agree a fixed or value-based fee in advance.
Can I pass my Harvey or ChatGPT subscription cost on to clients?
As a rule, no. ABA 512 treats general AI subscriptions as overhead, and California's May 2026 Practical Guidance says the same, adding that any AI cost you do pass through cannot be marked up without informed written consent. A per-matter cost, such as a usage-based document-processing charge, can be recovered at cost if the engagement letter says so.
Do I have to lower a fixed fee because AI made the work faster?
No. Virginia LEO 1901, approved by the Supreme Court of Virginia on 24 November 2025, confirms that a reasonable value-based fee need not be reduced because AI saved time. The fee must still be reasonable under Rule 1.5, and the client must have agreed the basis of the charge before the work began.
Do I have to tell clients that I used AI on their matter?
It depends on the jurisdiction and the use, but the trend is towards disclosure. ABA 512 requires informed consent where client data may be exposed, the CCBE guide of October 2025 says inform clients and let them object, and Clio's 2025 report found 78% of clients want to be told. Silence on the invoice is now a business risk as much as an ethics one.
Put this into practice
AI Lab for Lawyers: a live, hands-on course for practising lawyers
4 live sessions (8 hours), recordings included, taught by Dr. Niklas Schmidt of Wolf Theiss. Rated 4.7/5 from 381 ratings; alumni from Norton Rose Fulbright, Paul Hastings, Pillsbury and Taylor Wessing.
Related reading
Regulation & Ethics
Billing Clients for AI: What You Can Charge and What You Cannot
Lawyers may bill actual time spent using and checking AI or a fixed fee agreed in advance, but not saved hours, subscriptions or marked-up AI costs. Worked numbers inside.
10 min read
Guides
AI and the Billable Hour: Who Keeps the AI Dividend?
AI and the billable hour in 2026: associate rates at $798 and hours up 4.2% while Citi demands AI savings. What the ethics rules allow, three fee scenarios and a clear view.
9 min read
Regulation & Ethics
ABA Formal Opinion 512 Explained: What US Lawyers Must Do When Using AI
ABA Formal Opinion 512 applies six Model Rules to generative AI: competence, confidentiality, communication, candour, supervision and fees. What each duty requires in 2026.
8 min read
Regulation & Ethics
US State Bar AI Ethics Opinions: A 2026 State-by-State Guide
As of June 2026, 17 US jurisdictions plus the ABA have formal AI ethics opinions. None bans AI. They agree on verification, split on client consent and billing.
11 min read
Regulation & Ethics
Do You Have to Tell Clients You Use AI? Disclosure Rules and Practice
When lawyers must disclose AI use to clients under ABA 512, California, CCBE and ÖRAK rules, when consent is required, and a sample engagement-letter clause.
10 min read
Guides
What Legal AI Really Costs in 2026: Harvey, Legora, CoCounsel, Claude and ChatGPT
Legal AI cost as of September 2026, from €39 to $1,200 per seat per month, with Harvey, Legora, CoCounsel, Claude and ChatGPT prices and worked budgets for 5 and 50 lawyers.
10 min read