Regulation & Ethics
Billing Clients for AI: What You Can Charge and What You Cannot
Lawyers may bill actual time spent using and checking AI or a fixed fee agreed in advance, but not saved hours, subscriptions or marked-up AI costs. Worked numbers inside.
On this page
- Four opinions, one answer
- Why hourly billing punishes the firm that adopts AI
- Three billing models, with the numbers
- Subscriptions, tokens and disbursements
- What clients are demanding, as of September 2026
- Time entries that survive the client's chatbot
- Engagement-letter language for AI-assisted work
- A setup that works
You may bill the time you actually spend prompting, reviewing and verifying AI output at your normal rate, or agree a fixed or value-based fee in advance. You may not bill the hours the tool saved, charge for learning it, pass through a general subscription as a disbursement, or mark up AI costs without informed written consent. So say ABA 512, Texas 705, Virginia 1901 and California's 2026 guidance.
Four opinions, one answer
The US ethics position on AI and fees settled faster than almost any other AI question, and the opinions agree.
| Authority | Date | What it says on AI and fees |
|---|---|---|
| ABA Formal Opinion 512 | 29 Jul 2024 | Bill actual time, not time saved; no charge for learning the tool unless the client requested it; general subscriptions are overhead unless the client agrees otherwise; direct per-use costs may be charged at cost with disclosure |
| Florida Bar Opinion 24-1 | 19 Jan 2024 | No fee for time "saved" by AI |
| Texas Opinion 705 | Feb 2025 | Cannot charge for time "saved"; lawyers must hold "a reasonable and current understanding of the technology" and "cannot blindly rely upon" outputs |
| Virginia LEO 1901 | approved 24 Nov 2025 | A reasonable value-based fee need not be reduced because AI saved time |
| California Practical Guidance (generative and agentic AI) | 14 May 2026 | General AI subscriptions are overhead; no mark-up on AI costs without informed written consent |
None of these forbids a lawyer from profiting from AI. They forbid pretending. An hourly bill is a representation that the recorded hours were worked; a five-hour entry for a two-hour task is a false statement, whatever tool made it faster. The value-fee route is legitimate precisely because it makes no such representation. The full duty map, including competence and supervision, is in the ABA Formal Opinion 512 explainer; the seventeen jurisdictions with formal opinions as of June 2026 are in the state-by-state guide.
Why hourly billing punishes the firm that adopts AI
Take a familiar task: a first-pass review of a counterparty's master services agreement against your playbook, ending in an issues list. Before AI it took an associate five hours. With a review agent, it takes 0.4 hours to set up and prompt, 1.2 hours to read and correct the output and 0.4 hours to verify and write the issues list: two hours. At an illustrative $500 rate, the hourly invoice falls from $2,500 to $1,000. The subscription that made the saving possible sits in overhead. The client keeps the entire dividend and the firm has paid for the privilege.
This is not a corner case. Clio's 2025 Legal Trends Report estimates that 74% of hourly billable tasks have automation potential and that lawyers bill 2.9 of every 8 working hours. Jordan Furlong's line from 25 August 2026 is the one to remember: "Billing by the hour is like billing by the kilometre." A firm that automates on pure hourly billing is pricing itself down with every improvement.
Some firms have simply left. Crosby, the New York firm that Forbes profiled on 31 March 2026, has no hourly billing at all: $250 to $1,000 per contract, 13,000 contracts reviewed, $60m raised at a valuation of about $400m. Among tax practitioners, Blue J and CPA.com's June 2026 survey found 69% expecting to move to value-based, hybrid or fixed fees. The wider debate about who keeps the AI dividend is in AI and the billable hour.
And yet the hourly model has not collapsed. Citi's survey of 57 large firms (summer 2026) found demand for lawyer hours up 4.2% in the first half of 2026 against a 1.5% norm, with about half of firms saying AI has already affected pricing and three-quarters expecting the billable hour to be affected by 2028. The choice of model is real, and it is yours to make before the client makes it for you.
Three billing models, with the numbers
Same MSA review, same two hours of real work, same illustrative $500 rate. The euro version works identically.
| Old hourly (no AI) | A: Hourly, actual time | B: Fixed fee agreed in advance | C: Hourly plus pass-through | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hours recorded | 5.0 | 2.0 | 2.0 (recorded, not billed) | 2.0 |
| Invoice | $2,500 | $1,000 | $1,800 | $1,018 |
| Client saving against old hourly | none | 60% | 28% | 59% |
| Firm's effective rate | $500 | $500 | $900 | $500 plus cost recovery |
| Who keeps the AI dividend | nobody | client | split | client, minus the tool's marginal cost |
| Ethics conditions | Entries reflect real minutes; nothing for saved time or learning | Agreed before the work; reasonable under Rule 1.5; Virginia LEO 1901 | Per-use cost disclosed and charged at cost; no mark-up (California); subscription stays overhead |
Model A is the default if you change nothing, and it is fully compliant. It is also the model under which AI adoption is a straight revenue loss unless the freed hours are refilled with new work. Firms that choose it should at least measure the freed hours; GSK Stockmann reports 15 to 20% time savings on standard diligence and up to 75% on unstructured data rooms (29 April 2026).
Model B is where the profession is heading for repeatable work: NDA and MSA review, diligence per data room, standard filings, first-draft memos. The $1,800 in the table is 28% below the old hourly figure, which is the client's visible saving, and delivers the firm an effective $900 an hour, which is the firm's. Set the fee before the work and keep recording time even when you do not bill it; the record is your pricing data and your defence. Per-unit variants (Crosby's per-contract price, a per-data-room diligence fee) are Model B with a different unit.
Model C suits matters where the AI spend is large and metered, such as a diligence run over 100,000 documents on a consumption tier or an agent run billed by session-hour. The pass-through is at cost. The moment a margin is added, California's guidance requires informed written consent, and the ABA's disclosure requirement bites in any event.
Subscriptions, tokens and disbursements
Which costs can move to the client depends on how the vendor charges, not on how useful the tool was. Prices are as of September 2026; the full table is in what legal AI really costs.
| Cost type | Examples (Sep 2026) | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Per-seat subscription | Claude Team $25 standard or $125 premium per seat; ChatGPT Business $25 per seat; Microsoft 365 Copilot $30 per user per month; CoCounsel published range $104 to $639 per user per month; Harvey estimated at $1,000 to $1,200 per seat per month with a 20-seat minimum (secondary sources) | Overhead. Not chargeable unless the client agreed in advance |
| Metered usage | API tokens (Claude Opus 5 at $5 in and $25 out per million tokens); Claude Managed Agents at $0.08 per session-hour plus tokens; consumption components on platform contracts | May be passed through at cost, with disclosure; no mark-up without informed written consent |
| Client-mandated tool | A client's guidelines require a specific platform | Chargeable as agreed; learning time billable only because the client asked for that tool |
| Learning and set-up | Training, prompt building, configuring a project or playbook | Not chargeable |
| Verification | Reading every cited authority; testing a redline; correcting the analysis | Chargeable as review work actually done |
| Re-work after tool failure | Starting again because the output was unusable | Write it off |
The last row is a judgment call rather than a rule, but the direction of travel is clear. Oregon's Chief Judge Lagesen ordered appellate staff in March 2026 to log hours spent on fabricated authority, turning hallucination clean-up into a documented cost. Sullivan & Cromwell's April 2026 apology to Bankruptcy Judge Glenn for AI-generated fake citations in a filing shows what re-work looks like at an Am Law 10 firm. Nobody sensible bills a client for that time. The protocol that avoids it is in how to verify AI legal research.
What clients are demanding, as of September 2026
Clients have moved from curiosity to invoices. Modern Counsel reported on 3 September 2026 that Citi asks law firms to document AI savings while the average Big Law associate rate has reached $798 an hour, up 33% since 2023. The New York Post reported on 1 September 2026 that Morgan Stanley intends to put most outside work out to competitive bid with fixed fees by year-end. Meta's outside-counsel guidelines, from March 2026, refuse payment for tasks AI could have done.
The survey data say the same. Axiom's poll of 528 in-house leaders (9 July 2026) found 92% expecting or negotiating AI-related rate cuts, and few getting them. Deloitte's legal-department survey (30 June 2026) expects the hourly share of external work to fall from 72% to 44% within two to three years. The ACC/Everlaw report (2025) found 59% of in-house counsel seeing no savings from outside counsel's AI, and Gartner's Weston Wicks put the cause bluntly: "Law firms don't know how to charge clients for using AI tools."
The client's suspicion is not subtle. On the day Astra for Law launched, a Hacker News commenter wrote: "Cool, now you can pay an attorney $500/hr for them to prompt Astra for 30 minutes, and bill you like they spent the normal 8 hours." That is the accusation every AI-assisted bill has to be able to answer.
The answer is a model, not a discount. A rate cut on hourly billing concedes the dividend and keeps the kilometre problem. An offer to move repeatable work to fixed fees, with the AI saving visible in the price and the firm's margin preserved in the effective rate, gives Citi its documented saving and the firm a reason to keep investing. Client guidelines that require disclosure of tools and savings are covered in AI disclosure to clients.
Time entries that survive the client's chatbot
A 492-upvote thread on r/Lawyertalk (31 July 2026) describes the new reality: clients who dislike a bill run it through ChatGPT and send back the critique. Write narratives for that reader.
- Describe the lawyer's work, not the tool's. "Reviewed AI-generated issues list against MSA clauses 8 to 14; corrected indemnity analysis; verified three cited authorities in full" is a narrative. "AI contract review" is an invitation to dispute.
- Record actual minutes, contemporaneously. If the agent ran overnight and you spent 25 minutes reading its output in the morning, the entry is 0.4, not the two hours the task used to take.
- Keep a matter-level log of which tools were used. It supports the narrative, answers outside-counsel questionnaires and is the record Citi is asking for.
- Separate verification from re-work. Bill the first; write off the second.
- Never bill learning, prompt-library building or tool configuration to a client unless the client asked for that tool in writing.
- On fixed-fee matters, keep recording time anyway. Reasonableness challenges and next year's pricing both depend on it.
- Check narratives before the bill goes out. Linklaters built this in-house: a managing associate's "Narrative Checker" cleans about 1,000 time-recording narratives a minute (September 2025).
Engagement-letter language for AI-assisted work
The fee clause below does three things: fixes the actual-time rule, declares subscriptions overhead, and obtains the informed written consent that any pass-through needs. The optional fourth paragraph opens the door to Model B.
Fees, artificial intelligence tools and related costs
1. Where we charge by time, we charge only for time actually spent by our
lawyers and staff on your matter, including time spent instructing,
reviewing and verifying the output of AI tools. We do not charge for
time that AI tools save, or for time spent learning or configuring
such tools, unless you have asked us to use a specific tool.
2. Our subscriptions to AI tools are part of our overheads and are
reflected in our rates. They are not charged to you separately.
3. Where an AI tool is charged to us by usage on your matter (for example
per document or per unit of computation), we may pass that cost on to
you at cost and without mark-up, provided we have told you in advance
the basis on which it is charged. By signing this letter you consent
to this arrangement. [Delete this paragraph if no pass-through is
intended.]
4. [Optional] For the categories of work listed in Schedule [x] we charge
the fixed fees set out there. Those fees reflect our use of AI tools
and will not be adjusted according to the time actually taken, unless
the scope of the work changes as described in the Schedule.
5. Our use of AI tools, and your right to ask about or object to it, is
described in section [y] (Use of artificial intelligence tools).
Paragraph 3 is the California consent; paragraph 1 is Texas 705 and Florida 24-1; paragraph 4 is Virginia 1901 in contract form. Cross-refer to the disclosure clause rather than repeating it.
A setup that works
Divide your work into three buckets. Repeatable, AI-heavy work (NDA and MSA review, diligence, standard memos) goes to fixed or per-unit fees agreed up front, with time still recorded internally; the NDA review workflow is a natural first candidate. Bespoke advisory and contentious work stays hourly at actual time, with narratives written for a sceptical reader. Matters with heavy metered AI spend carry a disclosed pass-through at cost. Put the clause above into the next engagement letter, brief every timekeeper on the seven narrative rules, and prepare a one-page answer to the "document your AI savings" request before a client sends it. Module 5 of the AI Lab for Lawyers course covers the productivity and business-development side of this, including how to price AI-assisted work so the saving is visible without the margin disappearing. The in-house side of the negotiation is in the guide for legal departments.
Frequently asked questions
Can I bill clients for time saved by AI?
No. ABA Formal Opinion 512, Texas Opinion 705 and Florida Opinion 24-1 all say a lawyer billing by the hour may charge only for time actually spent, including prompting, reviewing and verifying output, and not for the hours the tool saved. If a task now takes two hours instead of five, the hourly client pays for two. The way to keep part of the saving is a fixed or value-based fee agreed before the work starts.
Can I charge clients for my AI subscription?
Generally not. Opinion 512 treats a general-purpose AI subscription as overhead, like research databases or word processing, unless the client agreed in advance to pay for it. California's 2026 Practical Guidance says the same and adds that AI costs may not be marked up without informed written consent. Metered charges tied to a specific matter, such as API tokens or per-document fees, may be passed through at cost if disclosed.
Do fixed fees have to be reduced because AI made the work faster?
No, as long as the fee is reasonable. Virginia LEO 1901, approved by the Supreme Court of Virginia on 24 November 2025, holds that a reasonable value-based fee need not be reduced because AI saved time. The fee must still pass the Rule 1.5 reasonableness test in your jurisdiction, and it must be agreed before the work is done, not set after you discover how quick it was.
Should I bill the time spent checking AI output?
Yes, where it is genuine review work. Reading every cited authority, testing a redline against the playbook and correcting the analysis is the lawyer's own work and is billable like checking a junior's draft. Time spent redoing a task because the tool's output was unusable is a different matter; the better view is to write it off, as you would a junior's failed first attempt.
Put this into practice
AI Lab for Lawyers: a live, hands-on course for practising lawyers
4 live sessions (8 hours), recordings included, taught by Dr. Niklas Schmidt of Wolf Theiss. Rated 4.7/5 from 381 ratings; alumni from Norton Rose Fulbright, Paul Hastings, Pillsbury and Taylor Wessing.
Related reading
Regulation & Ethics
ABA Formal Opinion 512 Explained: What US Lawyers Must Do When Using AI
ABA Formal Opinion 512 applies six Model Rules to generative AI: competence, confidentiality, communication, candour, supervision and fees. What each duty requires in 2026.
8 min read
Regulation & Ethics
Do You Have to Tell Clients You Use AI? Disclosure Rules and Practice
When lawyers must disclose AI use to clients under ABA 512, California, CCBE and ÖRAK rules, when consent is required, and a sample engagement-letter clause.
10 min read
Guides
AI and the Billable Hour: Who Keeps the AI Dividend?
AI and the billable hour in 2026: associate rates at $798 and hours up 4.2% while Citi demands AI savings. What the ethics rules allow, three fee scenarios and a clear view.
9 min read
Questions
Can I Bill Clients for AI? Time, Subscriptions and Value Fees
You can bill actual time spent using AI, not time it saved; subscriptions are overhead; value fees stay lawful. What ABA 512, Texas 705, Virginia 1901 and California say.
6 min read
Guides
What Legal AI Really Costs in 2026: Harvey, Legora, CoCounsel, Claude and ChatGPT
Legal AI cost as of September 2026, from €39 to $1,200 per seat per month, with Harvey, Legora, CoCounsel, Claude and ChatGPT prices and worked budgets for 5 and 50 lawyers.
10 min read
Regulation & Ethics
US State Bar AI Ethics Opinions: A 2026 State-by-State Guide
As of June 2026, 17 US jurisdictions plus the ABA have formal AI ethics opinions. None bans AI. They agree on verification, split on client consent and billing.
11 min read