AI Agents for Lawyers

Regulation & Ethics

Do You Have to Tell Clients You Use AI? Disclosure Rules and Practice

When lawyers must disclose AI use to clients under ABA 512, California, CCBE and ÖRAK rules, when consent is required, and a sample engagement-letter clause.

By Dr. Niklas SchmidtUpdated 13 November 202610 min read
On this page
  1. Clients want to know, and most are not told
  2. What the rules require, source by source
  3. The three triggers that turn "may" into "must"
  4. Notice or consent: match the tool to the obligation
  5. A sample engagement-letter clause
  6. Outside-counsel guidelines are writing the rule for you
  7. How to have the conversation without losing the client
  8. What to do this week

Usually yes in substance, though no major rulebook demands a blanket "we use AI" notice. ABA Formal Opinion 512 requires disclosure when AI use is relevant to the representation, when the client asks, or when informed consent is needed; the CCBE says inform clients and let them object; Austria's ÖRAK simply says disclose. Meanwhile 78% of clients want to be told and 35% of lawyers rarely tell them.

Clients want to know, and most are not told

The numbers are not close. In Clio's 2025 Legal Trends Report (autumn 2025), 78% of clients said they want to be told when their lawyer uses AI, 35% of lawyers said they rarely disclose it, and 36% of clients said they would be less likely to trust a lawyer who uses AI. That last figure keeps partners quiet. BigHand's pricing survey (16 September 2026) found 35% of partners uncomfortable discussing AI use with clients at all.

The UK picture has the same shape. Clio's UK and Ireland data, reported by the Law Society Gazette on 8 April 2026, put AI use at 89% of lawyers, with 81% of firms saying they disclose "at least occasionally" and 7% of clients recalling any disclosure. Whatever firms think they are saying, clients are not hearing it.

Corporate clients are no better informed. The ACC/Everlaw report (2025) found that 59% of in-house counsel do not know whether their outside firms use generative AI, and 80% neither require nor encourage it. Deloitte's legal-department survey (30 June 2026) found 58% of general counsel saying their firms "rarely or never" proactively discuss AI benefits.

Silence is not neutral: a client who hears nothing assumes the firm is either behind or hiding something.

What the rules require, source by source

SourceDateWhat it says about telling clients
ABA Formal Opinion 51229 Jul 2024Rule 1.4: disclose when AI use is relevant to the representation, when the client asks, or when consent is required. Rule 1.6: informed consent before client information goes into a self-learning tool; boilerplate consent is not enough
California COPRAC proposed comments and Practical Guidance13 Mar and 14 May 2026Proposed comments to six rules, including communication and confidentiality; exposing client data to AI is "revealing" it where there is "a material risk of unauthorized access, retention, or use"; guidance covers agentic AI; no mark-up on AI costs without informed written consent
NYC Bar Formal Opinions 2025-6 and 2026-222 Dec 2025 and 5 Aug 2026AI recording and transcription of client meetings and non-client calls: consent of all parties, no surreptitious recording, default is not to record
SRA Warning Notice on misuse of AI17 Aug 2026Solicitors must understand a tool "well enough to review its output critically"; prescribes no client-disclosure wording
CCBE Guide on generative AI2 Oct 2025Inform clients and allow them to object; flags hallucination and data-retention risks
ÖRAK (Austria), first KI-Tag19 Mar 2026Four rules: client data stays on EU servers, disclose AI use to clients, the lawyer keeps final responsibility, no client data for training; info sheet references § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA 2015
BRAK Hinweise zum Einsatz von KI (Germany)Dec 2024Tools that store or forward client data for model training breach § 43a Abs. 2 BRAO; the consent question comes before the disclosure question
EU AI Act Art. 50applies 2 Aug 2026Client-facing chatbots must identify as AI; a statutory duty independent of professional rules

Two things stand out. No US authority imposes a stand-alone duty to announce AI use; the duties are the ordinary ones of communication, confidentiality and fees, applied to a new tool, as set out in the ABA Formal Opinion 512 explainer. European professional bodies go a step further. The CCBE's October 2025 guide asks lawyers to inform clients and let them object, and the Austrian bar's four rules from its KI-Tag on 19 March 2026 include disclosure as a flat instruction. More on the Austrian and German position in AI rules for Austrian and German lawyers. Court disclosure is a separate question; see do I have to tell the court I used AI.

The three triggers that turn "may" into "must"

Client information goes into a tool that can keep it. This is the consent trigger. Opinion 512 requires informed consent before information relating to the representation goes into a self-learning tool. California's proposed Rule 1.6 comment would treat exposure to AI as revealing the information wherever there is "a material risk of unauthorized access, retention, or use". Germany's BRAK treats training on client data as a breach of § 43a Abs. 2 BRAO. And the Upper Tribunal in UK v SSHD [2026] UKUT 81 (IAC) said that pasting client letters into public AI tools puts them "in the public domain". Consumer accounts with training switched on fall squarely into this trigger, which is why most firm policies ban them for client work.

The client asks, or their guidelines ask for them. Rule 1.4 answers this one: if a client wants to know, you tell them accurately. Increasingly the question arrives in writing. Carlton Fields' Peter Winders, whose firm still prohibits generative AI for research and advocacy (23 March 2026), says most client outside-counsel guidelines he sees require naming the tool, obtaining written permission and estimating the cost savings.

AI does something the client would obviously want to know about. Three cases in practice. An AI notetaker in the meeting, where the NYC Bar's Formal Opinions 2025-6 (22 December 2025) and 2026-2 (5 August 2026) require consent of all parties and treat non-recording as the default; the setup is in AI meeting notes for lawyers. An agent that acts rather than drafts, which is why California's May 2026 guidance addresses agentic AI expressly. And any use that changes what the client pays, dealt with in billing clients for AI.

The answer to "do I need consent" depends on the account behind the tool, not the brand. As of September 2026 the tiers look like this.

Tool tierData terms (as of Sep 2026)Client-facing position
Consumer chatbots (ChatGPT Free, Plus, Pro; Claude Free, Pro, Max; consumer Gemini)ChatGPT trains on conversations unless the user opts out; Claude consumer accounts must choose, with opted-in data kept five years; consumer Gemini keeps activity 18 months, some of it read by human reviewersConsent trigger. Not for client confidences without informed consent; in Germany arguably not at all where training is on. Simplest policy: prohibited for client data
Business and enterprise tiers (ChatGPT Business and Enterprise, Claude Team and Enterprise, Microsoft 365 Copilot, Gemini Enterprise)Not used for training by default; retention governed by contract; zero data retention on some API arrangements onlyNotice in the engagement letter; consent generally not required; record the vendor evaluation
Legal platforms (Harvey, Legora, CoCounsel Legal, Lexis+ with Protégé)Contractual no-training terms; Lexis+ offers customer-held encryption keysNotice; name the platform where guidelines require it
Agents on your files and systems (Claude Cowork, Claude for Legal plugins, DMS connectors over MCP)Run under the user's permissions; iManage and NetDocuments connectors are permission-bound and loggedNotice plus a conversation where the agent touches strategy or sends anything; keep the human sign-off explicit

Vendor-by-vendor detail sits in the confidentiality checklist and the privacy settings guide. Rule of thumb: no-training enterprise tools need notice and a documented evaluation; consumer tools need consent you will rarely want to ask for.

A sample engagement-letter clause

The clause below gives notice, reserves the right to object (the CCBE model) and states the confidentiality floor. It does not replace specific consent where a retaining tool is used; the ABA is explicit that boilerplate does not do that job.

Use of artificial intelligence tools

1. We use software that incorporates artificial intelligence ("AI tools")
   to support our work for you, for example to summarise documents, review
   contracts against our standard positions, prepare first drafts and check
   our own research.

2. Every piece of advice and every document we deliver is reviewed and
   approved by a qualified lawyer of this firm before it reaches you.
   Responsibility for our work remains with us and is not affected by the
   use of AI tools.

3. We use AI tools only under contractual terms that prohibit the provider
   from using your information to train its models and that keep your
   information [within the European Economic Area / subject to
   confidentiality obligations no weaker than our own]. We do not enter your
   information into consumer AI services.

4. If we propose to use an AI tool on your matter in a way that goes beyond
   paragraph 3, for example a tool whose terms allow the provider to retain
   your information for its own purposes, we will explain this to you first
   and will not proceed without your consent.

5. You may ask us at any time which AI tools we are using on your matter,
   and you may instruct us not to use them. If you do, we will explain any
   consequences for timing or cost.

6. Where a meeting or call is recorded or transcribed by an AI tool, we will
   say so at the start and will stop if any participant objects.

7. Fees and costs relating to AI tools are dealt with in section [x] (Fees).

Austrian firms should keep the EEA wording in paragraph 3; it maps onto ÖRAK's rule that client data stays on EU servers. German firms may add a reference to § 43a BRAO. US firms should check their own state's opinion; the state-by-state guide lists the seventeen jurisdictions with one as of June 2026.

Outside-counsel guidelines are writing the rule for you

For any firm with corporate clients, the operative disclosure regime is increasingly the client's, not the bar's. The pattern Winders describes is spreading from technology companies to banks: Modern Counsel reported on 3 September 2026 that Citi asks law firms to document AI savings and Morgan Stanley is expanding competitive bidding. Axiom's survey of 528 in-house leaders (9 July 2026) found 92% expecting or negotiating AI-related rate cuts.

Three practical consequences. Keep a matter-level register of which tools touched which work; it answers guideline questionnaires in minutes and doubles as supervision evidence. Treat "name the tool" as routine, because the honest answer ("Claude Enterprise under a no-training agreement, CoCounsel for research, no consumer tools") is reassuring. And where a client's guidelines prohibit AI outright, price the matter on that basis and say so.

How to have the conversation without losing the client

The 36% of clients who say they would trust an AI-using lawyer less are reacting to a picture of a lawyer outsourcing judgment. The conversation works when it replaces that picture with the real one: a fast, error-prone assistant under supervision. Module 6 of the AI Lab for Lawyers course works through these client scenarios, including how to answer the confidentiality question with the vendor's actual terms in hand.

The client asksAnswer that worksAnswer that loses them
"Is my data going into ChatGPT?""No consumer tools. We use [tool] under a contract that prohibits training on your data and keeps it in [region]. Happy to send the terms.""Everything is encrypted, don't worry."
"Who actually checked this?""The draft was produced with AI assistance and reviewed line by line by [name]; every authority was read in full before it went out.""The AI is very accurate."
"Am I paying for the AI?""You pay for our time actually spent, not for the tool and not for hours it saved. On fixed-fee work the saving is already in the price.""Our rates already reflect our technology investment."
"Can you not use it on my matter?""Yes. It will take longer and may cost more; here is the difference.""Everyone uses it now."
"Should I be using it myself?""Not for anything you want to keep privileged. A Manhattan federal court held in February 2026 that a client's own consumer-Claude memos were not privileged."Silence.

The last row is the disclosure duty running the other way, and it is a service rather than a confession. In United States v. Heppner (S.D.N.Y., opinion 17 February 2026), Judge Rakoff held that a defendant's research memos drafted with consumer Claude were neither privileged nor work product because "Claude is not an attorney" and the terms allowed logging and disclosure; the Harvard Law Review has the analysis. Clients who paste your advice into a chatbot to check it, a habit common enough to fill a 492-upvote thread on r/Lawyertalk (31 July 2026), may be giving up more than they realise; see attorney-client privilege and AI.

What to do this week

  1. Put the clause above, adapted, into the next engagement letter that goes out, and into the standard terms at the next revision.
  2. Write down, in one page, which tools the firm uses for client work and under which account tier; this is the register you need for client guidelines and for your firm AI policy.
  3. Check whether any consumer accounts are in use for client matters. If so, stop, then migrate to a business tier.
  4. Set the notetaker default to off and script the one sentence you say when it is on.
  5. Brief every partner on the five answers in the table. The 35% who are uncomfortable are uncomfortable because nobody handed them the words.

Frequently asked questions

Do lawyers have to tell clients they use AI?

Not as a blanket rule in the US. ABA Formal Opinion 512 requires disclosure when AI use is relevant to the representation, when the client asks, or when informed consent is needed because client information goes into a tool that may retain or learn from it. The CCBE asks European lawyers to inform clients and let them object, and Austria's ÖRAK lists disclosure among its four practice rules. A short engagement-letter paragraph plus honest answers covers most cases.

Do I need client consent to use ChatGPT or Claude on their matter?

It depends on the account. Consumer tiers that train on conversations or retain them for the provider's own purposes require informed consent before client information goes in; most firms simply prohibit that use. Business, enterprise and API tiers with no-training terms need notice rather than consent, plus a documented vendor evaluation. California's proposed 2026 comment treats exposure to AI as revealing the information where there is a material risk of unauthorised access, retention or use.

Should the AI disclosure go in the engagement letter?

Yes, as notice and as a right to object, but not as the only step. The ABA says boilerplate consent in an engagement letter is not sufficient where informed consent is actually required, so anything involving a self-learning tool or an agent acting on the client's behalf needs a specific conversation. Austrian firms should add that client data stays on EU servers, which is one of ÖRAK's four rules.

Do I have to disclose an AI notetaker in client meetings?

Yes. The New York City Bar's Formal Opinion 2025-6 on client meetings and Formal Opinion 2026-2 on non-client calls require consent of all parties, prohibit surreptitious recording and set the default at not recording. Say at the start of the meeting that a transcription tool is running, say where the transcript is stored, and stop it if anyone objects. Many enterprise notetakers announce themselves automatically; check that yours does.

Put this into practice

AI Lab for Lawyers: a live, hands-on course for practising lawyers

4 live sessions (8 hours), recordings included, taught by Dr. Niklas Schmidt of Wolf Theiss. Rated 4.7/5 from 381 ratings; alumni from Norton Rose Fulbright, Paul Hastings, Pillsbury and Taylor Wessing.

Reserve a seat · €200 Maven money-back guarantee · certificate of completion

Regulation & Ethics

ABA Formal Opinion 512 Explained: What US Lawyers Must Do When Using AI

ABA Formal Opinion 512 applies six Model Rules to generative AI: competence, confidentiality, communication, candour, supervision and fees. What each duty requires in 2026.

8 min read

Regulation & Ethics

Billing Clients for AI: What You Can Charge and What You Cannot

Lawyers may bill actual time spent using and checking AI or a fixed fee agreed in advance, but not saved hours, subscriptions or marked-up AI costs. Worked numbers inside.

10 min read

Guides

Which AI Tools Train on Your Data? A Confidentiality Checklist for Lawyers

Which AI tools train on your data, plan by plan as of September 2026: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Copilot, legal vendors, plus bar rules and a 10-point checklist.

11 min read

Questions

Do I Have to Tell the Court I Used AI? Disclosure Rules by Jurisdiction

Whether you must tell the court you used AI depends on the judge: 30+ US federal districts require it, Illinois does not, England has no duty. How to check.

6 min read

Use Cases

AI Meeting Notes and Transcription for Lawyers: Consent, Privilege and Setup

AI meeting notes are ethical for lawyers only with all-party consent, a no-training data path and a retention rule. Bar opinions, tools and a file-note prompt.

8 min read

Regulation & Ethics

AI Rules for Austrian and German Lawyers: ÖRAK, BRAK and CCBE Guidance

ÖRAK's four AI rules and § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA bind Austrian lawyers; BRAK's § 43a BRAO line binds German ones; CCBE guides cover both. With a bilingual checklist.

11 min read