Regulation & Ethics
AI Rules for Austrian and German Lawyers: ÖRAK, BRAK and CCBE Guidance
ÖRAK's four AI rules and § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA bind Austrian lawyers; BRAK's § 43a BRAO line binds German ones; CCBE guides cover both. With a bilingual checklist.
On this page
- Three bars, three answers on telling the client
- Austria: four rules, five conditions and a sold-out KI-Tag
- Germany: BRAK's § 43a line and the DAV's § 43e answer
- The CCBE layer: the October 2025 guide and the 2026 technical guide
- Where the AI Act, the GDPR and works councils sit on top
- Mapping the rules to vendor terms
- The bilingual compliance checklist
- What to do this month
Austrian lawyers answer to ÖRAK's four rules: client data on EU servers, disclose AI use, the lawyer keeps final responsibility, no training on client data. German lawyers answer to BRAK's December 2024 Hinweise, which treat training on client data as a breach of § 43a Abs. 2 BRAO but impose no duty to tell clients. The CCBE's 2025 and 2026 guides sit above both.
Three bars, three answers on telling the client
The most consequential difference between Vienna, Berlin and Brussels is not about hallucinations or server locations, where the three bodies broadly agree. It is whether the client has to be told. ÖRAK says yes. The BRAK, in the text still current as of September 2026, says there is presently no such professional duty. The CCBE says inform the client and let them object. A firm with offices in both countries therefore runs two engagement letters or adopts the stricter rule everywhere.
| Body | Instrument and date | Tell the client? | Client data in the tool? |
|---|---|---|---|
| ÖRAK (Austria) | Four practice rules, KI-Leitfaden, Info-Folder (Sep 2025 to Mar 2026) | Yes | Only under a § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA 2015 agreement; EU servers; no training |
| BRAK (Germany) | Hinweise zum Einsatz von KI (Dec 2024, unchanged) | "Derzeit" no professional duty | Training on client data breaches § 43a Abs. 2 BRAO |
| DAV (Germany) | Stellungnahme 32/2025 (Jul 2025) | Not the focus | Permitted for service providers under § 43e BRAO without client consent |
| CCBE (Europe) | Generative-AI guide (2 Oct 2025); technical guide (23 Apr 2026) | Inform and allow objection | Data-retention risk flagged; deployment models from on-premise to SaaS |
The Czech Bar's opinion of 9 September 2026, which replaces its 2023 text and builds on the CCBE guide, lands on the German side: using AI "samo o sobě nezakládá automatickou povinnost advokáta informovat klienta", it creates no automatic duty to inform the client, and the Polish NRA's draft ethics-code amendment reported on 15 April 2026 says the same. Among the bars that have written anything down, Vienna and Brussels are the ones asking for disclosure. The case for one stricter standard across borders is in the page on telling clients you use AI.
Austria: four rules, five conditions and a sold-out KI-Tag
ÖRAK's first KI-Tag on 19 March 2026 in Vienna sold out at 250 participants, and the Anwaltsblatt report records the next one for 4 March 2027. The four practice rules fit on a business card: client data stays on EU servers, AI use is disclosed to clients, the lawyer keeps final responsibility, and no client data is used for training.
The detail sits in the ÖRAK KI-Leitfaden of September 2025 and in the information folder "Künstliche Intelligenz (KI) in Anwaltskanzleien" printed in Anwaltsblatt 2026/1 and filed in the member area under "Datenschutz/IT-Sicherheit → Cloud-Technologie und KI". Both rest on § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA 2015, which lets an external processor handle client data only when five cumulative conditions are met, as summarised by anwaltguru.at:
- the engagement of the processor serves the client's interests;
- the processor has been carefully selected;
- the processor has undertaken in writing to notify the lawyer immediately if served with a search warrant;
- the technical and organisational measures are state of the art;
- the client has been informed about the categories of processors the firm uses.
The escape hatch is the part most firms miss. If a provider refuses to sign the § 40 Abs 3 agreement, the Leitfaden allows "nur abstrakte und anonyme Fragen ohne Mandantenbezug", abstract and anonymous questions with no link to a client. Sub-processors that hold data "ausschließlich kurzzeitig und nicht dauerhaft", fully automated and without human access, are tolerated. You may ask a consumer chatbot how Gewährleistung under the ABGB works; you may not paste the client's Kaufvertrag into it.
ÖRAK has also put its name next to a product. Its partnership with AI:ssociate, announced on 2 July 2025, offers members the tool from €39 per user per month with three free months; it covers the ABGB, OGH case law and RIS and runs on EU servers. It is not the only compliant option, but its vendor has already accepted the bar's terms, a useful benchmark when negotiating with anyone else.
The national AI Act hub is the KI-Servicestelle at RTR, created by § 20c KOG, whose "KI-Kompetenz" section is the reference point when documenting Article 4 measures. This page is written from Vienna: Dr. Niklas Schmidt, who heads the firm-wide tax team at Wolf Theiss, is admitted as both Rechtsanwalt and Steuerberater and practises under this rulebook.
Germany: BRAK's § 43a line and the DAV's § 43e answer
The BRAK's "Hinweise zum Einsatz von KI" date from December 2024 and, as far as could be established, have not been revised since; the BRAK "behält sich vor, diese Hinweise zum geeigneten Zeitpunkt zu aktualisieren". Two lines carry the weight. First, tools that store or forward client data for model training breach the duty of confidentiality in § 43a Abs. 2 BRAO. Second: "Derzeit besteht keine berufsrechtliche Pflicht, Mandanten über die Nutzung von KI zu informieren."
The Deutscher Anwaltverein went further in Stellungnahme 32/2025, a 25-page opinion from July 2025 prepared by committees chaired by Prof. Thomas Gasteyer and Prof. Niko Härting. Its position is that the 2017 reform settled the cloud question: § 43e Abs 1 BRAO lets a lawyer give a service provider access to client secrets without client consent where necessary, § 203 Abs 3 S 2 StGB mirrors the rule, and reservations about cloud AI are "diskutiert und widerlegt". Firms may build "eigene KI-gestützte Systeme (Agents; interne Work-Flows)". The most striking sentence concerns verification: the Prüfungspflicht applies "sofern eine solche Überprüfung nicht explizit im Mandatsvertrag ausgeschlossen ist", meaning a client can contract out of the lawyer's duty to check the AI.
The courts have not read the waiver idea generously. In LG Frankfurt am Main, 2-13 S 56/24 (25 September 2025), a Schriftsatz contained three fabricated BGH quotations with false docket numbers and dates from a chatbot. The Leitsatz:
"Es gehört zu den Grundpflichten anwaltlicher Tätigkeit, dass ein vortragender Anwalt weder Fundstellen im Volltext erfindet noch von einem Chatbot vorgeschlagene Textquellen ungeprüft in einen Schriftsatz übernimmt."
— LG Frankfurt am Main, 2-13 S 56/24, as reported by Otto Schmidt on 12 January 2026
Inventing a citation and copying an unchecked chatbot citation are, on that reading, the same breach of core professional duties. The sanction was mild (the costs of the withdrawn appeal), and Germany accounts for only 11 of the 2,041 decisions in Damien Charlotin's hallucination database as of 14 September 2026, against 1,395 in the United States. Each entry nevertheless names a firm; the citation-checking protocol on this site is the cheapest insurance against joining the list.
The CCBE layer: the October 2025 guide and the 2026 technical guide
The CCBE Guide on the use of generative AI by lawyers of 2 October 2025 asks lawyers to inform clients about AI use and to let them object, and it foregrounds hallucination and data-retention risks. The technical guide, adopted on 27 March 2026 and published on 23 April 2026 (reported in the BRAK's Brussels newsletter), walks through deployment models from on-premise to SaaS, open-weight models and agentic AI. That is ground the BRAK's December 2024 text, written before the agent wave, does not appear to cover, which makes the technical guide the more useful document when evaluating a tool that acts rather than answers; the trade-offs are those in the comparison of open-weight and closed models for law firms.
For a CEE-wide practice the CCBE guide is the common denominator. The Hungarian bar's notice of 26 February 2026 declined to act as a "product licensor" and pointed members to it. The Czech Bar built its September 2026 opinion on it, named ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot, Gemini, Perplexity, Legora and Harvey, and recommended, without mandating, an internal AI policy; nine months earlier the Czech Constitutional Court had fined a Prague advocate CZK 25,000 (I. ÚS 3004/25, 10 December 2025) for a complaint built on invented case law.
Where the AI Act, the GDPR and works councils sit on top
Article 4 of the AI Act has required AI-literacy measures since 2 February 2025. The Digital Omnibus, Regulation (EU) 2026/1744, in force since 27 July 2026, reworded it into an obligation of effort ("take measures to support the development of AI literacy") but did not defer it, and national market-surveillance authorities have supervised it since 2 August 2026. The Commission's FAQ of 27 July 2026 says no certificates or tests are required and an internal training record is enough; there is no dedicated EU fine tier. The mechanics are in the page on Article 4 for law firms and the Digital Omnibus explainer; the GDPR questions to settle before signing are in the GDPR and AI tools guide.
Works councils are where German and Austrian practice diverge most sharply, and where a rollout most often stalls. In Germany, BAG 8 March 2022, 1 ABR 20/21 (Microsoft 365) holds that the abstract capability to monitor staff triggers co-determination under § 87 Abs 1 Nr 6 BetrVG; practitioner guidance from 31 May 2026 treats ChatGPT Enterprise and Copilot as co-determined, offline local models without logging generally not, and budgets four to eight weeks of pre-rollout work for 80 to 200 staff. Skipping it risks an einstweilige Verfügung and a Datenverwertungsverbot. In Austria, § 96a Abs 1 Z 3 ArbVG requires works-council consent for systems processing employee data beyond general particulars, but the Schiedsstelle can replace that consent under § 144 ArbVG; only control measures touching human dignity (§ 96 Abs 1 Z 3) carry an absolute veto. More in the page for employment lawyers.
Mapping the rules to vendor terms
The bar rules only bite at the point of signature. The table records what the sources used for this page state about hosting and training as of September 2026; where a source is silent the honest entry is "ask", and the vendor due-diligence questions show how.
| Tool | Data location as stated | Training on inputs | What the sources add |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI:ssociate | EU servers | No (ÖRAK partner terms) | From €39 per user per month; ABGB, OGH, RIS |
| Beck-Noxtua | IONOS and Open Telekom Cloud, Germany | Ask | €299 or €499 per licence per month net (third-party report, 7 September 2026) |
| Harvey | EU or Switzerland data regions | Ask | RIS and Gesetze-im-Internet statutes since 22 July 2025; no Austrian or German case law on its published list |
| Claude (Team, Enterprise, API) | Contract-dependent | Never used for training | Consumer Free/Pro/Max users must choose; opted-out chats kept 30 days |
| Gemini consumer app | Contract-dependent | Trains unless "Keep Activity" is off | Activity kept 18 months; Google advises against confidential input |
Two conclusions follow. A consumer chatbot on a personal account fails ÖRAK's fourth rule and BRAK's § 43a test unless training is switched off, and never satisfies § 40 Abs 3 because nobody at the vendor will sign anything. An enterprise tier can pass both once the written undertakings exist; the confidentiality checklist shows which settings to change on each platform.
The bilingual compliance checklist
German column for vendors and the Kammer; English column for international clients and group IT.
| # | Deutsch | English | Basis | AT | DE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Serverstandort EU/EWR vertraglich fixiert | Data residency in the EU/EEA fixed in the contract | ÖRAK rule 1 | Required | Advisable |
| 2 | Kein Training mit Mandantendaten, schriftlich | Written no-training undertaking | ÖRAK rule 4; § 43a Abs. 2 BRAO | Required | Required |
| 3 | § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA-Vereinbarung unterschrieben | § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA 2015 agreement signed, including the search-warrant notification duty | ÖRAK KI-Leitfaden | Required | n/a |
| 4 | Textform-Vertrag mit Dienstleister | Text-form contract with the provider | § 43e BRAO; DAV SN 32/2025 | n/a | Required |
| 5 | Mandanteninformation über Dienstleisterkategorien und KI-Einsatz | Client informed about processor categories and AI use | § 40 Abs 3 condition 5; ÖRAK rule 2; CCBE | Required | Not required by BRAK; recommended |
| 6 | Ausweichregel: nur abstrakte, anonyme Fragen | Fallback: abstract, anonymous questions only where no agreement exists | ÖRAK KI-Leitfaden | Required | Advisable |
| 7 | Prüfungspflicht: jede Fundstelle im Volltext geprüft | Every citation read in full text before filing | ÖRAK rule 3; LG Frankfurt 2-13 S 56/24 | Required | Required |
| 8 | Schulungsnachweis Art. 4 KI-VO | Article 4 training record | AI Act Art. 4; Commission FAQ | Required | Required |
| 9 | Betriebsrat eingebunden / Betriebsvereinbarung | Works council consulted or agreement signed | § 96a ArbVG / § 87 BetrVG | Where a council exists | Before rollout |
| 10 | Interne KI-Richtlinie beschlossen | Internal AI policy adopted | ČAK (recommended); CCBE | Advisable | Advisable |
Item 10 turns the rest into something a Kammer can inspect; a one-day route to a working document is in how to write a law firm AI policy. Module 6 of the AI Lab for Lawyers course works through these bar rules and the EU AI Act alongside the tools they govern.
What to do this month
- Pull the contract for every AI tool in use and test it against items 1 to 5. Anything without a written no-training clause and, in Austria, a signed § 40 Abs 3 agreement is downgraded to abstract questions until the paperwork exists.
- Decide the disclosure position once. A firm with Vienna and German offices should adopt ÖRAK's rule in both; it costs one sentence in the engagement letter and the CCBE guide points the same way.
- Write the Article 4 training record on a single page: who was trained, on what, when. No certificate is needed.
- Adopt the LG Frankfurt standard for court filings: no citation leaves the firm unread in full text, whichever tool produced it.
- If there is a Betriebsrat, open the § 87 BetrVG conversation now; four to eight weeks is the realistic minimum in Germany. Then diary a quarterly check of the ÖRAK member area, the BRAK newsroom and the CCBE IT Law page: the DAV's 15 September 2026 Anwaltsblatt focus on "KI-gestützte Rechtsberatung der Zukunft" suggests the German texts will not stay unchanged for long.
Frequently asked questions
Do Austrian lawyers have to tell clients that they use AI?
Yes, on the bar's own reading. Disclosure is one of ÖRAK's four practice rules, and § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA 2015 separately requires clients to be informed about the categories of external processors a firm uses. A sentence in the engagement letter naming AI providers as a processor category satisfies both, provided the vendor has signed the § 40 Abs 3 agreement.
Can German lawyers put client data into ChatGPT or Claude?
Only into a tier whose contract excludes training and gives the provider a written confidentiality obligation. BRAK's Hinweise treat tools that store or forward client data for model training as a breach of § 43a Abs. 2 BRAO, while the DAV says § 43e BRAO permits service providers under a text-form contract without client consent. Consumer accounts that train by default fail the first test.
What are ÖRAK's four AI rules for Austrian lawyers?
Client data stays on EU servers; AI use is disclosed to clients; the lawyer keeps final responsibility for the work product; and client data is never used to train a model. ÖRAK set them out around its first KI-Tag in March 2026 and in an information folder printed in Anwaltsblatt 2026/1, with the legal footing in § 40 Abs 3 RL-BA 2015.
What does the CCBE say about lawyers using generative AI?
The CCBE guide of 2 October 2025 asks lawyers to inform clients about AI use and let them object, and it highlights hallucination and data-retention risks. A separate technical guide adopted on 27 March 2026 and published on 23 April 2026 explains deployment models from on-premise to SaaS, open-weight models and agentic AI. The Czech and Hungarian bars point their members to it.
Does the EU AI Act add obligations for Austrian and German law firms beyond the bar rules?
Yes, but modest ones. Article 4 has required AI-literacy measures since 2 February 2025 and was not deferred by the Digital Omnibus; national market-surveillance authorities have supervised it since 2 August 2026. The Commission's FAQ says no certificates or tests are needed, only proportionate measures and an internal training record. Austria's KI-Servicestelle at RTR is the national information hub.
Put this into practice
AI Lab for Lawyers: a live, hands-on course for practising lawyers
4 live sessions (8 hours), recordings included, taught by Dr. Niklas Schmidt of Wolf Theiss. Rated 4.7/5 from 381 ratings; alumni from Norton Rose Fulbright, Paul Hastings, Pillsbury and Taylor Wessing.
Related reading
Guides
Which AI Tools Train on Your Data? A Confidentiality Checklist for Lawyers
Which AI tools train on your data, plan by plan as of September 2026: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Copilot, legal vendors, plus bar rules and a 10-point checklist.
11 min read
Playbooks
Write a Law Firm AI Policy in a Day: A Working Template
A working law firm AI policy template with ten clauses, commentary on each, EU and US variants and an hour-by-hour rollout plan that gets it signed in one day.
12 min read
Regulation & Ethics
EU AI Act Article 4: The AI Literacy Duty for Law Firms, Explained
Article 4 of the AI Act requires every firm whose staff use AI to support their AI literacy. In force since 2 February 2025, supervised nationally since August 2026.
7 min read
Regulation & Ethics
Do You Have to Tell Clients You Use AI? Disclosure Rules and Practice
When lawyers must disclose AI use to clients under ABA 512, California, CCBE and ÖRAK rules, when consent is required, and a sample engagement-letter clause.
10 min read
Regulation & Ethics
GDPR and AI Tools for Lawyers: Lawful Basis, DPIAs and Vendor Terms
How GDPR applies when law firms use Claude, ChatGPT or Copilot: controller and processor roles, lawful basis, DPIA triggers, transfers and vendor terms.
11 min read
Questions
Is ChatGPT GDPR-Compliant for Law Firms? A Practical Answer
ChatGPT can be used GDPR-compliantly by a law firm on Business, Enterprise or API terms with training off, a processor contract and a DPIA; consumer plans cannot. Seven steps.
7 min read